Good hand evaluation involves a lot more than mechanically counting points.

Source: January  2015 ACBL Bridge Bulletin   Spade Suit Heart Suit Diamond Suit club suit

Any reader of my articles knows all about counting points, but a separate vital question is, “What is my hand worth?”. Begin with the premise that not all high-card points are equal. For instance, partner opens 1Heart Suit and right-hand opponent passes.

Which of the following 6-HCP hands would you rather hold, or are they equal?
B is better than A because both your honor cards are “working”: They will help take tricks. The Spade SuitQ in the first hand may be a wasted value, but the Heart SuitQ in B is will be useful.

The lesson: It is better to hold secondary honors inside partner’s suit and aces outside, rather than the opposite.

Try another. LHO opens 1club suit, partner intervenes with 1Diamond Suit and RHO passes. Which of these hands is more valuable?

C is far preferable because those distributional values are apt to help partner in a diamond contract. The club suitA is pure, and both doubletons will limit partner’s major-suit losers, particularly in combination with the fourth diamond. Partner can draw trumps and still have diamonds in dummy to ruff losers. Just as secondary honors may be wasted when they don’t help win a trick, shortness may be wasted if each partner holds, say, a doubleton in the same suit.

In this auction, neither opponent has shown a major, so partner is likely to hold at least a tripleton in each major. Your doubletons are well located. While D has a higher point count, it has far less value. At least one of the queens may be wasted, and the flat distribution doesn’t help declare a diamond contract.

I would preempt to 3Diamond Suit holding C and pass with D.

In the next example, you open 1Spade Suit and partner raises to 3Spade Suit,10-12 points and at least four trumps. Which of the following two hands contains more slam potential?

E has 18 HCP and F has 15, but F might even produce a grand slam while E is worth no more than game. If this isn’t clear, start thinking in terms of tricks. Note the top-card losers with E: one spade, two hearts, one diamond and at least one club. How likely is it that partner can cover four of your five losers holding a maximum of 12 points? If partner holds three aces, you still need either the heart or spade finesse. Plus there’s the possible nuisance of a missing Spade SuitJ or a third-round heart loser. Even 5Spade Suit could come to grief if the opponents can cash a red ace and two clubs, or a singleton is on lead.

Now, consider hand F. An ideal dummy such as: yields a probable spade grand slam. Numerous other hands make 6Spade Suit a fine contract; the key is whether partner holds wasted values in hearts.

Holding E, sign off in 4Spade Suit. Holding F, make a slam try by showing your diamond control (4Diamond Suit). Even if partner signs off with 4Spade Suit , another slam try -5club suit – is in order. In the control bidding style where first-round controls are shown ahead of second, 5club suit shows second-round club control. You would have bid 4club suit holding both first-round minor-suit controls. Partner didn’t cuebid 4Heart Suit which is good news, suggesting that his values may usefully mesh with your suits.

Good hand evaluation involves a lot more than mechanically counting points.