Source:www.thebridgeexperts.comMarcelo Castello Branco**Source: wikipedia.Marcelo Castello Branco (born 1945) is a Brazilian bridge player from Rio de Janeiro. Among other successes, he was the winner of World Team Olympiad in Monte Carlo 1976, Bermuda Bowl in Perth 1989, and World Open pairs Championship in New Orleans 1978 and Geneva 1990. He is one of 10 players to achieve the Triple Crown of Bridge and the only player to have won the World Pairs twice – in Geneva with his most frequent partner Gabriel Chagas and in New Orleans with Gabino Cintra.
Good declarers are constantly drawing inferences from the cards played by the defenders. Honor leads usually reveal a touching honor; a high spot indicates that the opening leader is short or lacks high honors in the suit; declarer play is always based on deductions of this sort.
There are situations which are not as blatant. For example, if you eliminate the side suits in a trump contract and give up the lead so as to force the opponents to break up a suit in which you have Ax in your hand and Q10 in the dummy, if the opponents could choose which hand would win the throw-in trick and LHO won the trick (i.e. he will start the trick and dummy, with Q10, will be the next to play), you may be sure that LHO does not have the King. (If he had the King, he would have let his partner win the trick so as to play the problem suit correctly for the defense).
There are many discussions, in articles and books, about this theme. But it is not so common to find discussions about what may be called negative inferences, that is, inferences based on what the opponents did not do.
You are playing in 3NT after a strong 2 Club opening, a 2 Diamond response, a 3 Diamond bid by the strong hand, and 3NT by the weak hand finished the auction.
IMPs Dealer North. Neither Vul
A 7
A K Q 5
A K J 10 6 2
9
J 6 2
J 7 3
7 5 4
Q 7 4 2
West
North
East
South
2
Pass
2
Pass
3
Pass
3NT
Pass
Pass
Pass
The lead was 5. East won with the King, and played back the Jack, then the Ten, and finally the Four… and you are still alive since clubs were 4-4 originally. You discarded one spade and 2 diamonds from dummy.
West, upon winning the last club trick, played a spade to dummy’s (now) singleton Ace. And now you must guess diamonds to make your contract. You cash the Ace of diamonds (no luck there, all you see are small cards), and play 3 rounds of hearts, ending in hand with your Jack. Everybody follows suit.
Now you play a diamond from your hand, and West plays the 9. What should you do?
If you play the King (“Eight ever, nine never”), you are in effect playing the opening leader to have started with the 3 hearts he has shown, 2 diamonds (only), exactly four clubs, and therefore four spades, i.e., a 4=3=2=4 hand. And if you finesse in diamonds, you are playing for him to have one extra diamond, that can come only at the expense of the spade suit (since the count in the other suits is known by now). That is, you will be playing him for a 3=3=3=4 hand. In the first case, LHO would have had 4 spades and 4 clubs, and he would have led clubs from a suit such as A865. Is that likely? Is it not more probable that he would have led spades (from whichever holding he has in the suit)?
Reasoning like that, I finessed in diamonds, and was rewarded when East showed out.
If you are a math genius, willing to do this kind of calculations in your head while playing the hand (which is not my case, truth be told), you will see that the 4=3=2=4 hand is almost twice as likely as the 3=3=3=4 hand, which is an argument against the diamond finesse. You have to weigh this kind of consideration along with the psychological aspects of the choice of opening lead. As you know by now, in my opinion the psychological clue is dominant in our example hand, but there are situations in which the math is compelling; each player must make his own decisions at the table.
The Bridge Experts:
Welcome to our corner of the web! We are passionate about Bridge, and we are happy to provide consulting services to anyone, for free. You will see a donation form in our pages, but we will answer any question we receive to the best of our knowledge. Just move along to the Give us a hand! page and shoot us your questions!
We are Brazilian bridge experts. Our consultants include some legends of this game, as you can see for yourself in the Team page. We have played all kinds of systems, including Brown Sticker systems which are all but forbidden nowadays in top competition, but we are most comfortable with a natural structure. Brazilian top partnerships have played natural-based systems for over 30 years. We have lots of fancy gadgets (especially in the contested auction) which will be described in articles at our blog. If you ask a question in our contact page, you will also receive notifications about our articles, whenever they are posted (check our Articlespage)
We are planning on a series of exciting features which will be added to these pages as they become ready. Our goal here is to instruct bridge players of all levels with our pool of top-notch experts.
A 7
A K Q 5
A K J 10 6 2
9
